Custom Pillows

Name: Custom Pillows
Brand: MattressMakerssd
Availability: OutOfStock

Personalized Comfort for Better Sleep

Your pillow should fit you just as well as your mattress. Mattress Makers Custom Pillows are designed to match your sleep style, body type, and comfort preferences for better support night after night. Whether you sleep on your side, back, or stomach, we help you find the right loft and feel so your head, neck, and shoulders can truly relax. Handcrafted with premium materials and customizable fill options for comfort that feels made for you - because it is.

Choose from 5 High-Quality, Eco Friend Materials:

Buckwheat Hulls
Goose Down Feathers
Shredded Natural Rubber
Shredded Memory Foam
Shredded Polyfoam

Custom Pillows

$0.00

How to Build Your Custom Pillow

Visit one of our Mattress Makers showrooms to build your Custom Pillow in person.

Our team will guide you through the process, helping you test different fills, loft levels, and feels to create the pillow that fits your body and sleep style best.

Build, refill or remake your pillow in less than 5 minutes

Choose from different types of high-quality, eco-friendly materials.

Control your firmness level by adding or removing filling to get the thickness just right.

Backed by our commitment to better sleep: Free adjust and re-fluff for 5 years.

Visit a Location to Build Your Pillow

Ratings & Reviews

3,650 Night Mattress Guarantee

We offer a 10 Year (3,650 Night) Love Your Mattress Guarantee! If you're local and your comfort needs adjusting within the first year, we'll adjust your mattress for free.

Handcrafted in Southern California

Each mattress is handcrafted right here in San Diego, where we control every step of the process. By cutting out the middleman, we’re able to offer you high-quality mattresses at fair prices, all while supporting local craftsmanship.

Natural Materials

Our mattresses are crafted with natural, non-toxic materials like latex, wool, and cotton, providing a healthier, more comfortable sleep without harmful chemicals. Just pure comfort for you and the environment.

Can You Help Me Choose A Mattress?

Of course! Our complimentary customized comfort mapping station uses cutting-edge technology to analyze your pressure points in just a few minutes, then gives a personalized report of your body’s unique needs. We specialize in helping people find the perfect mattress based on sleep style, body type, and comfort preferences. Whether you want soft, firm, or something in between, we’ll walk you through it.

Do You Offer Free Delivery?

Delivery within San Diego county is $149 and scheduled within a few days of purchase. We also offer white-glove setup and removal of your old mattress for an additional fee.

Should I Buy A Mattress Online?

Yes! If you’re unable to easily visit one of our showrooms, and you know what you’re looking for! Buying a mattress online can be convenient and stress-free as long as you’re matched with the right one.

You can request a call with a Mattressologist and we’ll walk through your sleep style, comfort needs, and budget to help you confidently choose the best mattress for you. Whether you visit a store or click ‘buy’ from your couch, you’ll get expert guidance.

What Is Your Shipping Policy?

Local deliveries are scheduled within a few days of purchase. For orders outside of San Diego County, we ship nationwide with trusted freight carriers. Shipping times vary depending on your location, but we'll keep you updated every step of the way. Please give us a call for shipping to Alaska or Hawaii (858) 289-6165.

Shipping is $199
Delivery within San Diego county is $149

Do You Have A Warranty?

Yes! Every mattress comes with our 10-Year Love Your Mattress Guarantee – that’s 3,650 nights of stress-free sleep.

It covers defects and impressions beyond 1.5 inches and includes options for comfort adjustments during the first few years.

Our warranty for latex mattress is a 25 year warranty and our non latex mattress is 10 year warranty

What Is Your Return Policy?

Since each mattress is handcrafted, we don't accept returns in the traditional sense.

However, our 10-Year Love Your Mattress Guarantee includes comfort adjustments and exchanges to make sure you’re happy.

Our returns are within 120 days of receiving it and we recommend doing a comfort exchange before returning and there is a $289 service fee

How Long Will My Mattress Last?

Our mattresses are built to last at least 10 years—and many customers enjoy theirs even longer. With high-quality natural materials and solid craftsmanship, you’ll get long-term comfort and support.

What Makes Your Mattresses Different?

We handcraft every mattress right here in San Diego using better materials and a better process. No toxic foams, no shady sales tactics, and no middle-man - just ridiculously comfortable mattresses designed to last and backed by a 3,650 night love-your-mattress guarantee.

What’s The Difference Between All Your Mattress Types?

Each one is designed with different layers, firmness levels, and features to meet specific comfort needs. We’ll help you figure out which one fits your body and sleep preferences best with our complimentary customized comfort mapping system.

Do I Need An Adjustable Base For My Mattress?

You don’t need one, but many people love them. An adjustable base can help with snoring, acid reflux, circulation, and general comfort. All of our mattresses are compatible with adjustable bases.

Custom Pillows